The ultimate form of meditation, in my opinion,
is to stop the restless subvocalization that is going on both within our head
and within our larynx. The part of your brain that is responsible for speech is
called Broca’s area and it is always active, running speech patterns. Sometimes
its actions are not broadcast globally to the PFC and other association areas.
When this happens we have a brief respite from being aware of our internal
monologue. Usually however, not only is it broadcasting its speech to much of
the cortex, but it is broadcasting instructions for speech to the supplementary
motor areas, the premotor areas and the primary motor areas responsible for moving
the vocal cords in the larynx.
I am constantly tensing my throat,
silently going through the motions of speech. Language is always running
through my mind, whether it is me planning my day, me defending myself in a
hypothetical argument, me predicting what someone else will say, or me singing
the words to a song. Sometimes my mouth and tongue move with the words, sometimes
they don’t, but always my throat mimes the words. It has been difficult for me
to create respite from this interminable narrative.
I believe that what I have described is
a malady that afflicts nearly everyone. I also think that people that practice
advanced meditation focus on thinking without this internal dialogue. Surely it
is helpful, without it we would only practice speaking when we are really
speaking out loud to actual people. But I think that it afflicts us and we
should all learn to subdue it temporarily at will. I think that the only way to
do this is to: 1) become aware of it, 2) notice what it feels like to try to
stop it, 3) practice subduing it for as long as possible. I think the best way
is to try to subdue it from both ends: A) we can try to focus on the feeling
and sensation of letting our vocal tract go completely limp and relaxed, and B)
we can try to focus on the feeling and sensation of thinking without using
words.
Here are some helpful books on similar topics that I have enjoyed:
Here are some helpful books on similar topics that I have enjoyed:
Hi Jared
ReplyDeleteThis is an interesting take on it. Discussing this amongst some Buddhist friends we agreed that falling away of inner dialogue is a regular product of samādhi or intense one pointed absorption in a meditation object.
Of course there is Jill Bolte Taylor's description of her internal dialogue shutting down during her stroke - not a recommended method.
However some people report a more or less permanent loss of internal dialogue which is fascinating. One example is Gary Weber who discusses his experience in an interview on bloggingheads.tv.
Best Wishes
Jayarava
I wonder how exactly one would be able to think or to process abstract thoughts without this inner dialogue? It seems like the only thoughts besides inner monologues are emotions.
ReplyDeleteThinking without words - isn't this what primitive man did before the development of language? Are illiterate people, those who are aware of the heard word but not the written word, better capable of thinking without words?
ReplyDeleteCommenting from experience, it is actually possible to use a progressive relaxation technique to ultimately relax one's larynx and thereby stop discursive verbal thoughts. There is a lot of tension and micromovement that happen, in addition to just the larynx, related to thinking. This includes muscles in the neck, throat, jaw, lips, tongue, cheeks, brow and eyes. Try relaxing these outward manifestations of speech and thought in some progressive sequence that leads to relaxing your larynx. With practice, it's possible to become quite efficient at doing this so you can quickly stop your verbal thinking, anytime, anywhere. There are, however, other modes of thinking that aren't usually considered as thinking. Visualizing images, for example, and relaxing your larynx will not stop visualization and may even seem to increase it, although it probably just becomes more noticeable because you are no longer focused on word thoughts.
ReplyDeleteThere are a few impacts accessible in these units which can help a vocalist re-make a similar execution that was caught in a studio recording. Multi-voice agreement can take an artist's voice and afterward carefully clone it so as to quickly make a few amicability parts tuned in to the present vocal.Best vocal processor
ReplyDeleteI really enjoy reading and also appreciate your work.
ReplyDeleteinteraction design firms
Totally unique stuff is here really amazing!!!
ReplyDeleteinteraction design firm